
A Word About Blogging
August 16, 2007I found my cage well and truly rattled the other day; reading how Totally Un PC had had a a lecture on his use of grammar and clichés.
My reaction may have been a bit OTT, but on this subject I have a history.
My brother in law (BiL) ‘outed’ me as a blogger the other day, at a dinner table full of friends; the question most wanted to know is why? Why do I want to do it? (It’s OK BiL, all is forgiven and it was a nice compliment you paid me thank you!) Caught on the hop I wasn’t quite ready for the moment, I don’t think I explained very well, but the bottom line is that I like reading blogs and having found I have far to much to say on other people blogs and a growing confidence in my own abilities I decided to dive in and join the fun.
One of the friends was concerned that I took all I read as gospel, ‘You know it might all be fictitious.’ (Although I truly believe that there are prostitutes in Scotland and that someone lives next door to them.) No I don’t take every thing I read on a blog as the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth, for one thing it is a subjective personal account not investigative journalism, a statement for cross examination in court or an academic paper; nor do I take as gospel what I read in the press or watch on TV. To inform my thoughts and decisions; I look at what’s on offer, chuck in my own experience and knowledge and make up my own mind.
Blogs that I like make me think some of the following, ‘Oh I’d never thought about it like that’ ‘well I never knew that’ they also make me laugh, cry, and scream in sympathy with the frustration of the blogger. In a nutshell they are interesting, entertaining an informative and TUPC’s blog does all of that and more.
I think to criticise a blogger for their poor spelling, writing style or ‘standard of English’ (shudder, flash back to school) is out of order, for many people, myself included a blog is the first place they have ever ‘exposed’ anything they have written, it’s a place for the first ‘baby steps’ towards better writing. There is, it seems to me, a slow steady and insidious erosion of peoples self esteem when it comes to writing, from the moment a child picks up a pencil it seems to be told what it is doing wrong rather than right, (the fact that there is so much that is ‘wrong’ would suggest to me the teaching methods are less than ideal) the message is clear if you have poor written skills an inability to spell you should be ashamed, you are obviously stupid and ignorant.
An article in Sundays Observer newspaper reported how a tutor, a member of the Queens English Society at Imperial College London was so unimpressed by the standard of of English used by his students that he has ‘named and shamed them’. I can appreciate poor English is detrimental to clarity of academic writing and that better standards across the board are something to aspire to (and Lamb is quoted as saying ‘The rot thus extends from top to bottom in education’) but to me, the thrust of the article was a placing the blame upon the students, not the educational system that had led these presumably intelligent people to his academic institution.
To meet me you would probably say I was a confident person, I am happy stand up and speak in public, in front of an audience of a couple of hundred people if needs be, (although having looked at the Queens English Society web site, I don’t think they would like my accent) but ask me to write on a white board in front of anyone and I will flee. For me, my fear of ridicule and embarrassment about my writing (especially by teachers and academics) is so powerful that even to this day I will not write a comment in my children’s home work diary without first writing it in a word document and spell checking it. If this sort of tactic is not available to me (whenever I have to write) to allow me hide my ’shameful secret’ it is most likely I will say nothing; it’s a shame, because you never know I might have had an opinion worth listening to.



I don’t like seeing blogs that are badly written or poorly spelt but I would never comment on the entry criticising the blogger. I think that people who do are being pedantic as it’s what the entry is saying that is of relevance.
As to why I blog I don’t think that I’ve ever given a coherent reply when I’ve been asked. All I know is that I enjoy it and that it has become part of my daily life.
Unlike you I’m far happier writing than speaking in public.
A good, and interesting, entry, as always. Thanks.
Hi UHDD; i’m exactly the opposite from you when it comes to levels of confidence… ask me to stand in front of an audience and i’d be just as happy creeping under a rock, but i feel i’m queen of the world with a pen in my hands. And in fact i’ve read that a lot of writers have the same lack of social skills, choosing instead to manifest their thoughts in written form.
That said, i’ve taught esl and never, ever castigated people for spelling. There are usually several different ways to spell words and the acceptance of common usage is moot. Shakespeare and Spenser wrote words in whatever form they felt made sense at the moment, and you don’t see anyone critisizing THEM for literary stupidity!
To rip a strip off of someone for spelling (not even basic grammar or whether the sentence actually makes sense) is a bit mean, in my opinion. Especially when the core message of what the person is saying is ignored. After all, semantics and grammar only exist as tools to clarify what someone is trying to convey. They shouldn’t be art forms in and of themselves!
Without effective thought, these tools are useless. To expand the metaphor, you could be driving the most expensive car in the world; but without the driving force of an idea, the car ain’t going nowhere.
There’s nothing wrong with the way you write.
I love what you do write.
Please keep up the good work.
signed,
the schoolmarm
I is edificated to tertiary level, but why is it pedants think their views are more important than those less grammatically gifted?
ps the link you need is this one. I used to be ‘Vice Squad’ in her city, so she makes me laugh!
Thanks for that Noddy; Noddy ‘doing vice’ is an interesting mental image!!
I think that the same pre judgements are often applied to a persons accent, as well. (And why some many call centres are north of the border! You don’t here of many in Birmingham, sorry Brum, but your accent takes more flack than most!!) OK it not as much an issue as it was in say the 60’s, but its still there.
(Ok - reading through linked blog took up much of my lunch break…)
Please don’t ever let criticism put you off writing. To pinch a quote from Dr Seuss - “Those who mind don’t matter, and those who matter don’t mind.”
Over the years Mr Man has spent a lot of time in forums, etc. and he said that criticising another persons spelling or grammar is viewed so poorly on the net that the person doing it instantly loses all credibility in the eyes of the other readers.
I don’t think the intellect of an individual can be judged by what they write though - people excel in different ways. People have complimented my writing before, but actually I don’t think I have a very good vocabulary. On the other hand, I know you worry about your writing, but I can tell by what you write that you have a very extensive vocabulary and you are very knowledgeable, and in a normal conversation I probably wouldn’t know what you’re talking about! :o)
Jo, Dr Seuss will do for me, always wise words. Wish I had read his work as a child, but the only two books I can recall from my childhood are Winne the Pooh and ‘A Child’s Garden of Verses’ by Robert Louis Stevenson.
MrMW, thank you, but if I couldn’t articulate my knowledge I think I would consider myself to have scored a home goal! The holy grail for me would to be able to put my views across to a wide range of people, in away that is relevant to them.